Who Deserves a SAMA in 2015?


 

It’s time for the South African Music Awards again, and as usual, when going through the nominations, it’s clear that in most cases the SAMAs are growing ever more irrelevant.

For the past two years, The Con has argued that the SAMAs have become a giant joke that rewards the mediocrity of the established music industry at the expense of independent artists who have no label backing. And again in 2015, we stand by that claim. Why?

The SAMAs charge artists and labels to enter their albums into the awards, and this is problematic. But how they charge is also half the problem. Members of the Recording Industry of South Africa (RISA) get special treatment to the detriment of self-released artists or small niche labels. If you are a member of RISA, it costs R500 to enter an album in a category. If you are not a paid-up RISA member, you have to fork out R5 000. This means that by virtue of the SAMAs’ entry requirements and process, the commercial imperative of recorded music is already valued above the artistic merit of recordings.

In previous years, we argued that often the most interesting music in South Africa came from these independent artists, but instead of recognising these cutting-edge musicians, the SAMAs have been content to remain little more than a self-congratulatory exercise for the industry.

The SAMA judging process also suffers from a disturbing paucity of intelligence and musical appreciation. A case in point this year is veteran jazz legend Carlo Mombelli’s latest album, Stories, which in the Con’s minds is a contender for the finest jazz album released in 2014. But it didn’t even get nominated for the Best Jazz Album category, even though The Con has confirmed that it was indeed entered.

We’ve identified the nominated artists we feel are worthy of being recognised for their work in 2014, as well as a few that were not nominated but who we feel deserve some credit.

 

TBMO

 

Album of the year

The Con’s pick: The Brother Moves On – A New Myth

SAMA 2015 nominations: Beatenberg, Cassper Nyovest, The Soil, Ringo Madlingozi, K.O.

 

Mashayabhuqe-song

 

Song of the year

The Con’s pick: Mashayabhuqe Kamamba – TRVPMVSKV (Impendulo KaBaba)

 

Moonchild

 

Female Artist of the Year

The Con’s pick: Moonchild Sanelly – Rabubi EP

SAMA 2015 nominations: Bucie, Lulu Dikana, Maleh, Moneoa, Simphiwe Dana

mashayabhuqe - Alternative

Male Artist of the Year

The Con’s pick:  Mashayabhuqe Kamamba – Black Excellence EP

SAMA 2015 nominations:  AKA, Cassper Nyovest, Jimmy Nevis, Ringo Madlingozi, K.O.

 

Newcomer of the year

The Con’s pick: Mashayabhuqe Kamamba – Black Excellence EP

SAMA 2015 nominations:  Beatenberg, Cassper Nyovest, Duncan, Howie Combrink, Jeremy Loops

 

Language 12

 

Duo or Group of the year

The Con’s pick: Marcus Wyatt & Language 12 – Maji Maji in the Land of Milk and Honey

SAMA 2015 nominations: Beatenberg, Bittereinder, BlackByrd, McCoy Mrubata, The Soil

 

 Make Overs

 

Best Rock

The Con’s pick: Make Overs – Move Jinx Hand

SAMA 2015 nominations:  aKING, Prime Circle, Reburn, Taxi Violence, Zebra & Giraffe

 

BCUC

 

Best Alternative

The Con’s pick: BCUC – The Healer

SAMA 2015 nominations: Bittereinder, Bye Beneco, David Moffatt, Jeremy Loops, Tailor

 

Okmalumkoolkat

 

Best Rap

The Con’s pick: Okmalumkoolkat – Holy Oxygen EP

SAMA 2015 nominations: AKA, Duncan, Cassper Nyovest, Reason, K.O.

 

Proffesor

 

Best Kwaito

The Con’s pick: Professor – University of Kalawa Jazzmee Since 1994

SAMA 2015 nominations: L’vovo Derrango, Phi & Ginger, Professor, Thebe, Trompies

 

Aero-Manyelo-Herbs-Abroad-Cover

 

Best Dance

The Con’s pick: Aero Manyelo – Herbs Abroad

SAMA 2015 nominations: Black Motion, Bucie, Cuebur, Da Capo, DJ Clock

 

Carlo Mombelli

 

Best Jazz

The Con’s pick: Carlo Mombelli – Stories

SAMA 2015 nominations: Herbie Tsoaeli, Kyle Shepherd, Marcus Wyatt, McCoy Mrubata, Nduduzo Makhathini

 

 

, ,


Notice: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /usr/www/users/thecohkmkf/wp-content/themes/currents/comments.php on line 22
Comments are closed.